When she was good,
She was very good indeed,
But when she was bad she was horrid
--There Was a Little Girl,
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
What are little girls made of?
What are little girls made of?
Sugar and spice
And everything nice,
That's what little girls are made of
--19th cen. nursery rhyme
She may be weary, women do get weary,
wearing the same shabby dress
And when she's weary,
try a little tenderness.
--Try a Little Tenderness,
Frank Sinatra
~I think ugly girls should be
shot at birth by their parents.
It's bad enough being born a girl...but ugly and clever...
~fancy you're clever, do you?
~I rather hope so. I'm done for if I'm not!
--My Brilliant Career (1979)
___________________
Myth, media and reality: Tough Grrrls
The
Marines recently pushed back the requirement that female recruits successfully accomplish 3 pull ups as more than 50% could not manage that feat,
"delaying the prerequisite as it
tries to
integrate thousands of women into combat roles by 2016, the Associated
Press reports."
The myths surrounding female vigor
have shifted over time. There were the fabled Amazons who possessed
physical prowess and goddesses who wielded the power to command others
to do their killing. There was Boudica and Joan of Arc, and the rare
women throughout history who went to war under cloak of male's clothing.
Patriarchy
emphasized female reliance upon the male's brawn, and diminished her
further through representations of the hysterical woman at once enslaved
to her hormones and therefore a threat to the male's surety of his
lineage, while at once ensuring the male's place as the satisfier of her
wanton lusts.
Freud introduced us to the male's fear of engulfment and the
vagina dentata,
and the ever-receding possibility of sexual parity issuing not only
from the inherent structural differences between the sexes but also our
own particular neurosis and psychoses. It would seem the sexes would be
forever consigned to opposite sides of the cave, cowering, glowering and
licking their chops. The agreement allowing for one-on-one cohabitation
was the marriage contract, a prospect based upon the distribution but
not equalization of labor.
The 20th century ushered in
film, actors, computer graphics and a social ethos which says,
"Free to Be ... You and Me." In a generation we went from female cops like
"Cagney and Lacey" -- of indeterminate sexual orientation -- to sexy
killers like Ziva David on the popular television series
NCIS. The boys can
play with dolls, and girls can watch G. I. Jane and Lara Croft Tomb
Raider. It's all good.
Fast forward 30 years and the
new tough females are borderline or straight-out psychotic killing
machines, like the female characters on the t.v. series
Person of Interest.
Forget bringing home the bacon and frying it up in a pan -- she does
not care about making you feel like a man, because she's too busy
co-opting your positions
. Or so the media would have you believe.
The press hypes the new aggressive Alpha female and most accept the idea of women in combat and the death of the draft. But Ranger's position has remained steadfast: women should not be in the combat arms or maneuver or deployable units.
He
does not hold this position because he is a misogynist or a dinosaur,
but because the facts bear out his position. He is sorry to stomp on the
parade of those who maintain the happy thoughts like "anyone can grow up
to be President.
"
The Army teaches that a unit is as strong as its weakest link. Soldiers train hard to achieve a strong chain that can pull a heavy load.
Individual training strengthens the individual, and these single units
are integrated into unit training after which they become deployable
assets. This is the basis of all combat effectiveness and unit cohesion.
Combat is neither glamorous nor does it have redemptive value.
In training, men frequently lose weight and get beaten down hard. It is
doubtful that women could perform on the brute physical level of men
like Medal of Honor recipients
Staff Sergeant Jon Caviani and
SSG Roy Benavides,
who killed enemy in close quarters combat with their fighting knives
after having suffered grievous wounds (Caviani put his knife in a man's
brain and was forced to leave it as it became bone welded and would not
extract.)
SSG Fred Zabitowsky broke his back and ribs but
managed to pull three men out of a downed helo and drag them to an
extraction area. He was burned, broken and gunshot, yet he hefted
soldiers onto his back.
Like
so many MOH recipients, Zabitowsky accepted the award on behalf of his
fellows, whom he credited with operating at the same level of heroism. (We have written about Ranger associate Paul Longgrear, who led his men out of the Battle of Lang Vei with a broken ankle and head wound.)
These acts are those of the fighting male operating full bore.
Unlike Title IX in women's sports, the battlefield may not be arrayed
so that women fight only their physical peers. The fact is, most men who qualify for military participation can physically dominate most women in a fight scenario. This is why most Olympics sports are segregated by gender -- it is not to give them the disadvantage, but rather to offer them parity in competition.
This "separate but equal" is fair.
Ranger anticipates objections that these are extreme scenarios, but this is what the military's "chain" concept is all about.
Twenty-four Medals of Honor were recently
belatedly awarded
to men who had been denied their awards due to racial or religious
prejudice. Ranger challenges anyone to read these MOH citations and
image a female performing the same deeds.
It does not come down to bravery or patriotism alone, it comes down to sheer physical capabilities.
So
what's the solution? Put women on 155, 8 inch, 4.2 mortars? Will they
pull motor stables with the mechanized and Armor? Will they carry a
Barrett 50 or a GPMG? Will women hump ammo as assistant gunners? Can
they throw a grenade and fight with men in close quarters combat? Endure
the filth and privations of the battlefield?
Ranger does not believe combat effectiveness should be compromised in the name of raising the glass ceiling.
[cross-posted @ RangerAgainstWar.]
