But
unfortunately war never stopped on 11 November 1918. In the period just after the 1918 Armistice
there were at least 27 violent transfers of political power, many accompanied
by violent civil wars. Not just in Russia.
Winston Churchill in his arrogance commented
sarcastically: "The war of giants has ended, the wars of the
pygmies begin." Yet Europe
between Armistice Day in November of 1918 and the Treaty of Lausanne July 1923
was the most violent place on the planet.
Four million people died during that period as a result of armed
conflict. Millions more died of the
great influenza pandemic between 1918 and 1920, much of it had been spread by
war. And hundreds of thousands died of
starvation due to those post-Armistice conflicts.
Finn
nationalist <i>”volunteers”</i> launched the Kinship Wars in Estonia,
Karelia, the Murmansk Oblast, Ingria and Petsamo.
The
Aster Revolution broke out in
Budapest. Then Romanians and Czechs invaded Hungary;
and also in Hungary there were periods of both Red Terror and White Terror.
Yugoslavia
sparred with Italy over Rijeka. Poland did the same with Czechoslovakia over Cieszyn Silesia, and with
Germany over Poznań, and with Ukrainians
over Eastern Galicia.
There
was the violent rise and fall of the Bavarian Soviet
Republic in Munich, and the Spartacist Uprising
in Berlin. The Freikorps also fought
against the communists in the Baltics, Silesia, Poland and East
Prussia.
Ditto
for an attempted Communist
putsch in Vienna. And ditto for the
Slovak Soviet Republic in Prešov.
The
last Sultan, Mehmed VI, was overthrown in Turkey. And Turks fought their own War of
Independence
against France, Italy, Britain, Armenia and Greece.
There
was the well-known Russian Civil War between Reds and Whites with various
interventions by French, British, Australian, Italian, Canadian & US troops
in Arkhangelsk; British, Canadian, Italian, Chinese, Japanese &
US troops in Vladivostok; Romanian troops in Bessarabia; Greek troops in the
Crimea and Odessa and Kherson; Estonian troops in northwestern Russia; and the
Czech Legion throughout Siberia. Plus
Russia repressed breakaway republics in the Caucasus and the western
borderlands, and the kulaks, anarchists and moderate socialists. Ukrainians, Belarusians, Lithuanians, Estonians
and Latvians fought against each other and against the Russians.
In Bulgaria there was the coup against Prime
Minister Stamboliyski by IMRO. His hand
that signed the Treaty of Niš
was cut off. Then he was blinded, tortured
and his head cut off, which sparked bloody uprisings
and repression.
I would guess I missed many more of the conflicts
during that period. And the above mostly
speaks of Europe. There was also much bloodshed
in Africa, Asia and the Americas during that timeframe to include the Rif War
in North Africa, the revolt in Egypt, the Amritsar massacre (and others) in
India, the March 1st Movement in Korea, the Warlord Era in China; the
continuation of the Mexican Revolution, and many more. FDChief is correct: the hairless ape has
never figured out a way to solve problems without violence.
IIC there were thousands of Americans somewhere in Siberia, not (just?) in Arkhangelsk.
ReplyDeleteSven -
DeleteYes, see above. I had mentioned US troops in both Archangelsk AND Vladivostok.
Interesting that the approximate 8,000 troops of the American Expeditionary Force in Siberia were primarily guarding (and in some cases operating) the railways. Also they were there as a precaution in case the Japanese tried to annex the Amur Region. And they assisted the Czech Legion to evacuate from Russia. Their Commander, General Graves, did not let them fight against the Bolsheviks. This was despite pressure from the British who wanted them to participate on the side of the White Army under Admiral Kolchak.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_S._Graves
Unlike the AEF in Northern Russia who while under British command actively fought against Red Army units under Trotsky. They participated in the Battle of Tulgas on Armistice Day 1918, the Battle of Shenkursk two months later, and the Battle of Bolshoi Ozerki two months after that. Trotsky's troops outgunned them in artillery. And there was mutiny among the Whites they were fighting alongside, and also a mutiny among a unit of the British Royal Marines. Additionally there were murders of Allied advisors attached to White troops, a Kafkaesque forerunner of the 'insider' attacks going on 100 years later in Afghanistan.
And it's a good reminder to those who like them some war (Hi, John Bolton, you dangerous fuck!)because "war works" that instead war usually works to produce all sorts of unintended consequences, most of them bad, or at least not what those who started the wars anticipated.
ReplyDeleteAnd it's worth noting that you bring in the Jallianwallah Bagh ("Amritsar") massacre. The Great War produced a pack of troubles for the British in India culminating in the USAPATRIOT Act of it's time, the "Rowlett Act" of 1919, that gutted whatever civil liberties the British had allowed their Indian subjects. The protests that stemmed from that wartime atrocity led directly to Jallianwallah Bagh and, from there, to independence in 1957.
ReplyDeleteWhile it's unlikely that British raj could have survived the post-WW2 imperial devolution, the mistakes made and brutalities inflicted by the British as a result of "wartime emergencies" in WW1 ensured the doom of the raj and the tide of bitter hatreds unleashed.
So while we don't seem to be able to figure out a way to solve our problems without violence, we ALSO don't seem to see that "solving" them WITH violence seems to create as many - and often more - problems. Christ, we're stupid.
Anybody has some decent reading material/reading hints on these "western" Operations in the Russian Far East? Admittedly, mike's comment made me aware of the scale of the action for the first time...
ReplyDeleteMiles Hudson's "Intervention in Russia 1918-1920" is a decent one.
DeleteDennis Gordon's "Quartered in Hell" is one I have been wanting to read. Very spendy though. But it has four and a half stars on Amazon. I tried to get my local library to borrow it from a major library, but struck out.
Looks like the University of Michigan has a nice collection of primary sources for the Archangel Expedition here: https://bentley.umich.edu/research/catalogs-databases/polar-bear/polar-bear-expedition-history/
DeleteFDC - That makes sense, since most of the 339th were drafted and/or recruited out of Michigan.
DeleteThanks! Seems I'll need to hope for a nearby university library, or maybe spend the €15+shipping on a used US import of the Hudson.
Delete